Whodunnit Daily - Hint for September 13, 2026

The scene: The rare-fish tank was drained overnight at the aquarium. 5 keepers had after-hours passes. That puts Cole, Mira, Hugo, Sam and Cara in the frame — and once you line their statements up, they can't all be telling the truth.

Stuck on today's case, The Cracked Aquarium? Here's a nudge to help you solve it yourself - no spoilers.

The statements

• Cole: “Hugo is innocent.”
• Mira: “Cole is telling the truth.”
• Hugo: “Cole is innocent.”
• Sam: “Cole is innocent.”
• Cara: “It was Cole.”

Your hint

Find the statement that can't be true alongside the others. The suspect it implicates — or the one whose own claim collapses — is your liar.

Re-read the statements with that in mind before revealing anything.

Still stuck?

See the full answer & who is guilty →

Play today's puzzle · Past answers · New to these puzzles? Read the guide